markg183: How do we compare?

Last updated : 30 September 2005 By Mark Gilmore

League One: Consolidation for the Gills, or should we be demanding instant success?
Despite our recent improvement in results, including a win over Portsmouth the League Cup, and a recent victory over Chesterfield, the Gills’ league form so far this season hasn’t met the expectations of some fans. Pre-season ambitions of a play-off place or automatic promotion still exist, but a lot of hard work is needed if we are to make up lost ground. I thought I would look at how previous teams, relegated from the Championship (second flight), have fared in their first season in League One (third flight) and ask if our expectations are out of reach for this season, or if that play-off place can indeed be achieved.

League One has seen many teams come and go in our 5 year absence. Both Crewe Alexandra and Brighton have been relegated to League One, only to bounce straight back up the following season. Their respective performances have created a benchmark for teams in our position and provided a tough task to follow. So what were the aspects in their respective teams that gave them the bouncebackability needed?

Crewe’s promotion season of 2002/2003 was one of great triumph in key areas. Despite finishing second to hotshots Wigan Athletic, they managed to find three skilful goalscorers and establish a solid defence. Rob Hulse and Dean Ashton hit 43 goals in all competitions between them, with Rodney Jack contributing a further 16 goals. Defensively, they kept 17 clean sheets in the 46 league games, managing to earn them many vital away points. Manager Dario Gradi managed to regroup the side after relegation, and install fresh and positive ideas into the players. They played attractive, passing football throughout the side that enabled them to score plenty of goals and they fully deserved their 2nd place for that season.

Brighton’s Cardiff-assisted promotion of 2003/2004 came via the play offs in a tense victory. Leon Knight was Brighton’s star man, arriving at the start of the season and banging in 27 goals in all competitions. Other players managed to chip in with the goals, with nobody reaching double figures though. Their collective defensive performance was solid, conceding only 43 goals in league competition. Brighton did however, manage to make Withdean Stadium a fortress, winning 17 home matches, and losing only two. Following Steve Coppell’s departure, Mark McGhee was installed as manager in October of 2003 and managed to conserve their early form, keeping players hungry for places. A final standing of 4th was well deserved, and eventually enough to secure promotion.

So how do we compare with the achievements of these sides? We certainly have a player who is capable of scoring 20+ goals this season, in Darren Byfield. He needs to maintain his confidence and stay fit though, as without him in the team we have often found goals hard to come by in recent outings. As for a regular striking partner, we have seen many players come and go so far, of which, Paul Shields has made the most promising impact. Sadly, problems with injuries have been a regular occurrence in his career so far, and could limit his impact. Neil Harris is a more reliable option, although looks unlikely to bring many goals to the side with our current passing system.

Yes, sadly we are still adopting the long ball approach to our passing system for the majority of time during matches. The times where we have managed to pass the ball effectively on the ground (e.g. the first 20 minutes of the second half at Brentford) have been successful, enabling us to create more opportunities for the attackers. The current passing system is severely limiting the numbers of goals scored at the moment. Cooper made it a primary issue to deal with this, and he must continue to work with the team on effective distribution of the ball if we are to create enough chances for the strikers to score the goals needed to gain us a play off spot, like Leon Knight managed to achieve at Brighton.

Defensively we have started shakily. Chris Hope and Ian Cox began as our main partnership in central defence but have frequently looked uneasy in their position and made costly mistakes. Luckily the revitalised Leon Johnson has brought some physical presence and pace back to the defence in the absence of Hope and Cox due to injuries. Brent Sancho has established himself in the side and also looks more assured and composed than his Trinidad counterpart, Ian Cox. Jason Brown however, has maintained a good start with solid displays in goal. His place in the side is a must, and is exactly the kind of player we need to push for promotion.

At the moment though, we rarely look like keeping a clean sheet, unless our opposition are having a very bad day at the office. This is hampering our away form, with an example like Brentford proving that we seem unable to keep an away lead, with that game finishing 1-1 despite us taking the lead.

We have to play wide midfielders who will track back and help out the full backs. Richard Rose has often been exposed due to Matty Jarvis concentrating to heavily on attacking and not enough in defence. Danny Jackman looks a better bet on the left side of midfield, as he will track back more effectively, leaving Jarvis to be used for extra firepower from the bench in the last 30 minutes, as his recent performances have surely warranted this demotion.

Simple defensive procedures have often been forgotten in moments of chaos that have cost us dearly, which have been a long term problem of the past seasons. We need to avoid getting caught out from set pieces, as we are conceding goals to easily, and must toughen up in the air, ensuring that our marking is tight. Crewe’s good defensive form from their promotion season was built from no nonsense defending from players like Efe Sodje and Richard Walker, and a reliable keeper in Clayton Ince. We must ensure that we find this reliability and stop making erratic mistakes.

As it stands, the Gills lie only 4 points from the play offs, despite lying in 20th position after the first quarter of the season. A bit of luck with injuries will certainly help us out and the return to full fitness for key players like Danny Spiller and Paul Shields will give Neale Cooper more options to play with. He must also have confidence to keep players out of the side if they aren’t performing, despite their history or position at the club.

Recent games have seen improved results, but there are still underlying problems which must be solved if we are to make a serious bid for promotion this season. It is certainly achievable, and we haven’t made a disastrous start to League One. In Neale Cooper we have found a manager with honesty and awareness and he will know the areas that need working on.

Otherwise like Walsall and Sheffield Wednesday in previous years, this season will be one of consolidation, and a mid-table finish. Although we should be aiming for the play offs, another season to build up this side could make it stronger and better equipped for a sustainable push for promotion next season, which in the long run, could be better for the team, and allow us to stabilise our financial problems. Either way, there will surely be an improvement on last season’s position - something that we will all relish!